WHO ME? An Extremely True Crime Podcast with The Batmin! EP. 38 w/ Penny Plunderer (Bobby Moynihan, Scott Aukerman, Brett Morris)

March 17, 2026

The Dark Knight brings in his one of his oldest and least-understood foes, PENNY PLUNDERER (Scott Aukerman). A penny for his thoughts: WHERE IS SHE?!

More Episodes

2 months ago The Robber Cop faces his most confounding foe yet…HARLEY QUINN (Caitlin Reilly). Stay thirsty my friends.

3 months ago Thing about to get WET as the Caped Crusader, The Dark Knight himself, interrogates the living crap out of AQUAMAN…

3 months ago Today’s guest is…a little OUT THERE. Prepare yourselves for the Rubber Cop to interrogate Charlotte McKinney, yes the real actress…

4 months ago The Dark Knight brings on a supporting character for a change, it’s Wayne Enterprises CEO and Batmin’s gadget master LUCIUS…

8 months ago CinnaBatmin is back in the New Year, and he brings on his childhood friend turned nemesis, HUSH (Taran Killam). Who…

8 months ago The Jaunty Batmin and Alfred throw a special New Year’s Eve party and invite some very special guests like Superman…

All Episodes